Debunked: Gnonsense about Jesus Having a Wife

By David Kind
Oh Boy! A new Gospel!!!
Every few years, it seems, there is a big hubbub as someone unveils some "new," "early Christian" writing that supposedly sheds new light on Jesus and the faith of the early Christians. A few years ago it was the "Gospel of Judas". Before that it was the "Gospel of Mary Magdalene," before that the theoretical proto-Gospel of "Q" (manuscript evidence for which no one has ever found or seen). This week the stir is being caused by the discovery by Harvard professor Karen King, of yet another gospel which is being touted as the "Gospel of Jesus’ Wife." But do these fragments and writings do what St. John says the Scriptures are for? Do they bring us to believe that Jesus is the Christ and that, believing, we have life in His Name?
This new "gospel" is actually just a small fragment of text found on a scrap of papyrus (about the size of an early iPod nano) preliminarily dated to some time in the fourth century (the 300s). It is written in Coptic, leading the scholars involved to believe it originated in Egypt. The scrap contains only eight lines of text on the front, none of which are complete sentences, and only five legible words on the back. It is being called a gospel because it contains phrases like, "The disciples said to Jesus" and "Jesus said to them." According to the article posted by the Harvard Divinity School, the translation of the front of the papyrus reads:
Line 1: not [to] me. My mother gave me li [fe]
Line 2: The disciples said to Jesus
Line 3: deny. Mary is worth of it (or) deny. Mary is n[ot] worthy of it.
Line 4: Jesus said to them, "My wife..."
Line 5: she will be able to be my disciple
Line 6: Let the wicked people swell up...
Line 7: As for me, I dwell with her in order to...
Line 8: an image...
The line that is causing such a stir is the fourth where it could appear that Jesus is talking about His wife; who, because line three mentions a "Mary," might have been Mary Magdalene according to Karen King. Others in recent times have made the same claim, based on the fact that Mary Magdalene is held up as an important disciple in other writings like the Gospel of Mary Magdalene and the Gospel of Thomas. This rather new idea was made popular in the book The DaVinci Code by Dan Brown (and in the movie version with Tom Hanks). However none of these other texts actually say that Jesus was married, let alone that Mary Magdalene was his wife. In fact there are no texts written by anyone from before the fourth century (assuming this scrap is really that old) that make the claim that Jesus was married. Read the text of the papyrus and you will see that what we have in this case is an awful lot of speculation based on a piece of old paper that doesn’t even contain a single complete thought on it!
But what about these other gospels that don’t show up in the Bible? And what does this newly discovered papyrus fragment have in common with them? There are dozens of writings, claiming to be about Jesus or claiming to have been written by His disciples, that are not in the Bible. Most of them, like this scrap of papyrus, come to us from Egypt. Most of them were discovered in the last century, meaning that they were never used by the Church as Scripture (If they had been they wouldn’t have been lost). None of them were written before the late second century (more than 100 years after Jesus death and resurrection). And nearly all of them were written by people who held to a strange mystical spirituality called "gnosticism."
The Gnostics were people who believed that there was a secret knowledge that only certain people had within them which would free their spirit, which, they said was, a little piece of God trapped within a person, from its material bondage (so your body and everything material was thought of as a kind of prison). Though there were dozens of flavors of gnosticism, all of them were rejected by the Church and their teachers condemned as heretics. Much of what St. John wrote in his epistles (See especially 1 John 1:1-5) and some of what St. Paul wrote in his, was in response to the early gnostic heresy.
What do the Gnostic gospels tell us about Jesus and the Christian faith? Not much, it turns out. Most of them borrow some material from the Biblical Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. But what is not borrowed directly from the Bible is often so bizarre that, even if one were to take them seriously, they would provide precious little useful information in terms of who Jesus is and what He supposedly taught. For example, in the Gospel of Judas Jesus is portrayed as someone who needs help freeing His inner divinity through suicide (the cross) and Judas is portrayed as the hero who helps Him do it. In the Gospel of Mary Magdalene Jesus delivers a cryptic discourse to Mary Magdalene who is portrayed as the chief disciple. In the Gospel of Thomas Jesus supposedly says that in order to be saved Mary Magdalene would have to become a man first. So take teachings that are incoherent, then mix in lots of crazy visions, detached sayings, and weird stories, and you'll get an idea of how most of these so-called gospels read.
Nowadays some scholars are promoting these gnostic texts as alternative witnesses of early Christian beliefs. By presenting these bizarre texts as legitimate expressions of Christianity, they claim to be showing the world that there were other forms of Christian faith which existed peacefully along side of orthodox Christianity. Karen King admits that she has based her career on challenging the Christian faith and critiquing what she calls "the master story of Christianity." What King and others like her are really challenging is the authority of the Holy Scriptures as the Word of God. The Bible, they claim, is merely one version of what people believed about Jesus, and that there is no one truth but several alternative versions of it.
But the Word of God recorded in the Holy Scriptures is not one version of the truth. According to Jesus and the Apostles it is The Truth. Jesus makes the claim that the Word of God is Truth in John 17 and that that Word cannot be broken in John 10. So how could there be multiple versions of the truth? And concerning the writing of the Scriptures, St. Peter says (2 Peter 1): "...we did not follow cunningly devised fables when we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but were eyewitnesses of His majesty." And again, a few verses later: "...no prophecy of Scripture is of any private origin, for prophecy never came by the will of man, but holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy Spirit."
The Gospels in the Bible were given by God through His apostles. These Gospels are clear, true and trustworthy. Most importantly, they bring us repentance unto faith in Jesus, who, they witness, was crucified for our sins and alive again on Easter. The "Gospel of Jesus’ Wife" and the other gnostic gospels? Well, that's another story...
Rev. David Kind is pastor of University Lutheran Chapel in Minneapolis, Minnesota and is a former member of the Higher Things Board of Directors.
This article was originally published on the Higher things website in September 2012.

Related Posts

Recent

Archive

 2020
 June
Reflections: June 2, 2020Under the Cross: Living in the Light of ChristReflections: June 3, 2020This Just In: Countering Chaos with ChristReflections: June 4, 2020Dean's List: Jesus Ain't Done YetVideo Short: The Athanasian CreedLive Bible Study: June 4, 2020Reflections: June 5, 2020Debunked!: The Unreachable CarrotLive Bible Study: June 5, 2020Live Bible Study: June 6, 2020Reflections: June 6, 2020Reflections: June 7, 2020Reflections: June 8, 2020Video Short: June 8, 2020Foundations: You Are What Jesus Says You AreHymnal 101: June 9, 2020Live Bible Study: June 9, 2020Reflections: June 9, 2020Under the Cross: Baptized, Not GayVideo Short: June 9, 2020Reflections: June 10, 2020Foundations: Preface and Proper PrefaceVideo Short: June 10, 2020Reflections: June 11, 2020Speaking of Faith: How to Defend Infant Baptism and Have Fun Doing ItVideo Short: June 11, 2020Live Bible Study: June 11, 2020Reflections: June 12, 2020Video Short: June 12, 2020Foundations: No You-Gotta with JesusLive Bible Study: June 12, 2020Reflections: June 13, 2020Reflections: June 14, 2020Reflections: June 15, 2020Video Short: June 15, 2020This Just In: The Real EnlightenmentLive Bible Study: June 15, 2020Live Bible Study: June 16, 2020Reflections: June 16, 2020Helpful Things: Spilling the Tea on Generation ZVideo Short: June 16, 2020Video Short: June 17, 2020Reflections: June 17, 2020Live Bible Study: June 17, 2020Foundations: Your Father's LoveReflections: June 18, 2020Video Short: June 18, 2020Live Bible Study: June 18, 2020Dean's List: You're Covered on Judgment DayReflections: June 19, 2020Video Short: June 19, 2020Debunked: I Don't Think This Verse Means What You Think It MeansLive Bible Study: June 19, 2020Live Bible Study: June 20, 2020Reflections: June 20, 2020Reflections: June 21, 2020Reflections: June 22, 2020Video Short: June 22, 2020Under the Cross: Hope in Suffering, Not Apart from ItLive Bible Study: June 22, 2020Foundations: Better Than BulletproofReflections: June 23, 2020Video Short: June 23, 2020Speaking of Faith: Tell What Jesus DidVideo Short: June 24, 2020Reflections: June 24, 2020Live Bible Study: June 24, 2020Reflections: June 25, 2020Musica Sacra: College Hymn FailVideo Short: June 25, 2020Live Bible Study: June 25, 2020Reflections: June 26, 2020Digging Deeper: By Design: Creation and RedemptionVideo Short: June 26, 2020Reflections: June 27, 2020Live Bible Study: June 26, 2020Reflections: June 28, 2020Live Bible Study: June 29, 2020Reflections: June 29, 2020Video Short: June 29, 2020Under the Cross: The First Time I DiedVideo Short: June 30, 2020Foundations: Can, Cannot, and VocationHymnal 101: Church SeasonsReflections: June 30, 2020
 July
Reflections: July 1, 2020Digging Deeper: Mixing It Up with Religion and PoliticsLive Bible Study: June 30, 2020Video Short: June 30, 2020Live Bible Study: July 1, 2020Live Bible Study: July 2, 2020Dean's List: Your Permanent RecordReflections: July 2, 2020Video Short: July 2, 2020Debunked: Enough Isn't EnoughReflections: July 3, 2020Reflections: July 4, 2020Reflections: July 5, 2020Reflections: July 6, 2020Video Short: July 6, 2020Under the Cross: Beautiful, Heartbreaking WorldVideo Short: July 7, 2020Live Bible Study: July 6, 2020Flex: Christ's Cancel CultureReflections: July 7, 2020Speaking of Faith: Third Article EvangelismReflections: July 8, 2020Live Bible Study: July 7, 2020Video Short: July 8, 2020Live Bible Study: July 8, 2020Video Short: July 9, 2020Under the Cross: The Sophia Worthy of ReceptionReflections: July 9, 2020Live Bible Study: July 9, 2020Helpful Things: Get Your Youth Talking!Reflections: July 10, 2020Video Short: July 10, 2020Reflections: July 11, 2020Live Bible Study: July 10, 2020Reflections: July 12, 2020Reflections: July 13, 2020Video Short: July 13, 2020Digging Deeper: Approaching Feminism with the Mind of ChristLive Bible Study: July 13, 2020Musica Sacra: Hymns Are for ProclamationReflections: July 14, 2020Video Short: July14,2020Video Short: July 15, 2020Live Bible Study: July 14, 2020Foundations: Stand by MeReflection: July 15, 2020Live Bible Study: July 15, 2020Dean's List: Your Vote Is a Gift for your NeighborReflections: July 16, 2020Video Short: July 16, 2020Live Bible Study: July 16, 2020Debunked: The Truth about Jeremiah 29:11Reflection: July 17, 2020Video Short: July 17, 2020Reflections: July 18, 2020Reflections: July 19, 2020Video Short: July 20, 2020Reflections: July 20, 2020Foundations: The Life You Now LiveReflections: July 21, 2020Video Short: July 21, 2020Foundations: Heaven on Earth TogetherLIVE BIBLE STUDY: July 21, 2020Speaking of Faith: The Curious Case of AgnosticismLive Bible Study: July 22, 2020Reflections: July 22, 2020Live Bible Study: July 20, 2020Video Short: July 22, 2020Video Short: July 23, 2020Reflections: July 23, 2020Under the Cross: Pushing Back with CompassionLive Bible Study: July 23, 2020Video Short: July 24, 2020Digging Deeper: SpiriligiosityReflections: July 24, 2020Live Bible Study: July 24, 2020Reflections: July 25, 2020Live Bible Study: July 25, 2020Reflections: July 26, 2020Live Bible Study: July 27, 2020Flex: Lutherans on FacebookReflections: July 27, 2020Video Short: July 27, 2020Video Short: July 28, 2020Foundations: CrucifloodLive Bible Study: July 28, 2020Reflections: July 28, 2020Video Short: July 29, 2020Speaking of Faith: Campus ChristianReflections: July 29, 2020Live Bible Study: July 29, 2020Dean's List: Baptized, Ready to DieLive Bible Study: July 30, 2020Reflections: July 30, 2020Video Short: July 30, 2020Video Short: July 31, 2020Debunked: The End Times--Still All About JesusReflections: July 31, 2020

Categories

Tags

1 John 4 1 Peter 3 1 Peter 5 1 cointhians 1 1 corinthians 10 1 corinthians 1 1 corinthians 3 1 corinthians 4 1 corinthians 5 1 corinthians 6 1 corinthians 7 1 corinthians 8 1 corinthians 9 1 john 1 1 kings 19 1 pete 3 1 samuel 10 1 samuel 12 1 samuel 13 1 samuel 14 1 samuel 15 1 samuel 16 1 samuel 17-18 1 samuel 17 1 samuel 18 1 samuel 19 1 samuel 1 1 samuel 20 1 samuel 23 1 samuel 24 1 samuel 25 1 samuel 26 1 samuel 28 1 samuel 2 1 samuel 31 1 samuel 3 1 samuel 4 1 samuel 5 1 samuel 6 1 samuel 8 1 samuel 9 1530 1corinthians 1 1corinthians15 1corinthians1 1john 2 1john 3 2 Nations 2 corinthians 5 2 samuel 1 2 samuel 20 2 samuel 21 2 samuel 22 2 samuel 5 2 samuel 6 2020 2peter 1 9/11 ;unishment Abimelech Abraham Absolution Acts 10 Acts 11 Acts 12 Acts 13 Acts15 Adam Air Force Angelou Apostles' Creed Areopagus Asher Athens Augsburg Augustine Ben E King Benedictus Bethel Bethlehem Bethuel Bible study Bilhah Blesses Jacob Boaz Boggess Book of Life Book of Prayer Broadway Buddha CDC COVID CTCR Called Out Culture Canaan Castillero Catholic Charles V Christ crucified Church Communion Compline Concordia Corinthians Corona Corrow Curry DNA Daniel Dan Daughters of Canaanites David Dinah Divergent Divine Service Drosendahl Eden Ehrhard Eighth Commandment El Capitan Emmanuel Enlightenment Ephesians 2 Esau maries Ishmaelite Esau marries Hittites Esau Eucharist Eve Exodus 3 Ezekiel Facebook Father Fenker Fifth Commandment First Article Fisk Flood From Above Gad Galatians 2 Gen Z Generation Z Genesis 12 Genesis 13 Genesis 14 Genesis 16 Genesis 17 Genesis 19 Genesis 1 Genesis 20 Genesis 21:10-21 Genesis 21 Genesis 22 Genesis 24-25 Genesis 24 Genesis 25 Genesis 50 Genesis 5 Genesis 6 Genesis 7 Genesis 8 Genesis George Floyd God increased apotted and striped flocks God's Word God's promise Good Friday Good News Goodman Grace Greek Grim Reaper Hale Han Solo Hill Holy Baptism Hosanna Hunger Games I am IGen Immanuel Instagram Isaac lies about Rebekah Isaac Isaiah 64 Isaiah Issachar Issues Etc Jacob flees Easu Jacob marries Leah Jacob marries Jacob returned to Canaan Jacob sent to Laban Jacobs ladder Jacoby Jacob Jairus Jeremiah Joanna Joel 2 John 15 John 17 John 18 John 1 Johnson John Joseph Joshua 10 Joshua 23 Joshua 24 Joshua 4 Joshua 6 Joshua 7 Joshua 8 Joshua Judah Judges 2 Judges 3 Judgment Day Kahoot Keith Kopitske Kosche Kruschel LCMS-U LGBTQ LSB Laban cheated Jacob Laban Last Day Lazarus Leah Levi Lord appears to Abraham Lord's Supper Luke 15 Luke 16 Luke 1 Luke 6 Luke 9 Luther Lydia Magnificat Mandelbrot Mark 13 Mark 5 Mark 9 Martha Martin Luther Mary Mass Matthew 15 Matthew 16 Matthew 4 Matthew 7 Matthew McCrorey Memorial Day Micah 7 Michelangelo Minneapolis Mize Monty Python Morales Muhammad Nain Naphtali Nicene Creed Nicodemus Nones Nunes Old Testament Onesiumus Ostapowich Paradise Passover Patmos Pauls Pelikan Pew Research Pharisees Phil 4 Philemon 17 Philemon 18 Philippians 2 Philistines Pierson Plano Polycarp Preface Preus Proverbs 14 Proverbs 15 Proverbs 16 Proverbs 17 Proverbs 20 Proverbs 22 Psalm 119 Psalm 123 Psalm 18 Psalm 22 Psalm 23 Psalm 27 Rachel steals fathers gods Rachel Rebekah Reuben Revelation Romans 1 Romans 3 Romans 5 Romans 6 Romans 8 Rosebrough Rouser Ruth 2 Ruth Sabaoth Sacraments Salome Salomi Sanchez Sanctus Sarah laughed Sarah Sayers Siddhartha Simeon Sletten Snapchat Social shaming Sodom Son St Paul St. Paul St.Peter Star Wars Sticks before watering trough Supper Taylor Swift Ten Commandments Test Texas Third Article Tribulation Trickery Turkey Twitter Uzziah Vieker Well of Shibah Woelmer Word Zachariah Zebulun Zilpah abide abortion absolve academic active acts 14 acts 15 acts 16 acts 18 acts 19 acts 20 acts 21 acts 22 acts 23 acts 24 acts 25 acts 26 acts 27 acts 28 acts 2 acts 8 acts 9 acts2 acts addiction adultery adults advice aerospace agnostic alcoholic all christians who have been baptized almighty altar guild altar angels animal answer anti-christian antinomians antioch antiphonal anxiety apologetic apostles apostle archaeology archangels arius ark assurance athanasian atheism atheist audience augustana authority babies babylon baby banquet baptism baptized barnabas beliefs best constuction betray bible bigots birthright blessing blind blood blues body bonhoeffer borghardt borg borhgardt bread bride of Christ bride brothers brown buetow burial calendar cancel culture cancel candle casket catechism catechize change chant children choir christianity christ clerical cling codependency coin college colors colossians 1 colossians 2 colossians 3 colossians 4 comfort of forgiveness comfort compassion conferences confessions confession confess confidence confirmation conversion coronavirus corporate council covenant creation creed cross crucified crucifix cruciflood culture current events cwirla daily bread dan brown danger darkness dash dead dean death debtors defense defensiveness deistic deliverer demons depression deserve destroy deuteronomy 18 disagreement disaster disciples dishonesty dispensational disruption diversity divorce doctrine donkey door doubt doxology dream dystopian earthquake easter ecclesiastes 1 ecclesiastical egypt election elizabeth embarrassment emotions endure enemy engineering enlightened ephesians 4 ephesians 5 epistle equilibrium estates eternal life evangelism evil evolution excuses exhortation exile exodus 20 experience extra nos ezekiel 1 failure faithful faith fall false teachers false teaching family famine fate fear feast feeling wheel feelings feminism fire font foolishness foolish for you foreigners foretaste forgiveness of sins forgiveness forgiven forgive fortress fractal freedom from sin freedom freshman fringes fulfillment funeral fun future galatians 1 galatians 3 galatians 4 galatians 5 galatians 6 gay gender generations generosity genesis 15 genesis 2 genesis 3 genesis 4 genesis11 genetic gerhardt gifts gift girlfriend gloom gnosticism golf good fruit good work good gospels gospel government grandma gratitude greatness groom guard haiti happiness harmony healingl heinz heirs hell heresy hidden bias high school historic history holy spirit holy trinity holy homework homosexuality honor hope hostility humility hurt hymnal hymnody hymn hypocrites i never knew you i samuel 15 iPad iPhone identity idolatry image-bearer imitate imposters imputed incurvatus inheritance intentional forgiveness internet interpretation invitation irreducible complexity isaiah 6 isolation israel ivory tower jeremiah 23 jerusalem jesus jewish job38 job john 10 john 12 john 13 john 14 john 16 john 19 john 20 john 21 john 3 john 6 john the baptist joshua 1 joshua 2 joshua 3 joy judas judgemental judgement judges 13 judges 14 judges 15 judges 16 judges 4 judges 6 judges 7 judging judgment seat justification justin martyr karma katrina keep keseman keys kind kingdom kohlmeier kuhlman lange large catechism laugh law lectionary legacy lemon lentil stew lex credendi lex orendi liberation life-changing light lion liturgical liturgy live lord's prayer lord\'s prayer lord\\\'s prayer lord\\\\\\\'s prayer lord\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'s prayer lords prayer lords supper lost love your neighbor love lowly luke 11 luke 14 luke 18 luke 19 luke 21 luke 22 luke 23 luke 24 luke23 luke24 luke5 lust lutheran madden magruder manifestation marginalized populations mark 10 mark 16 mark 6 mark 8 martyrdom martyr mary magdalene masks matthew 28 matthew 5 matthew28 matthew3 means of grace measure mental health merciful mercy metaphor microagression mietzner millennium missionaries missionary modernism money moses mountaintop movement multiply offsprings murder musician mythology myths name nations nation natural disaster natures nature negative neighbor new life new man news nicea noah non-masked numbers 21 numbers 22 numbers 23 numbers 24 numbers 35 numbers27 numbers32 obedience obey old Adam omans 3 omans 6 onesimus opposition orders ordinary ordination organ overcome pandemic panmillennialist papacy papyrus paraments passive pastoral care pastors pastor patriarch paul peers pentecost people perfection persecution persons person peter philemon 8-9 philemon philippians 4 philosophy politics poor pope positive post-Christian postmodern poverty power practices praise prayer pray pregnancy pregnant presence pride procrastination prodigal son prodigal professor promised land promises promise prophecy prophets prophet proverbs 10 proverbs 13 proverbs 24 proverbs 25 proverbs 27 proverbs 31 proverbs 3 proverbs 5 proverbs 8 proverbs 9 proverbs22 provision psalm 13 psalm 20 psalm 25 psalm 28 psalm 2 psalm 48 psalm 51 psalm 54 psalm8 psychologists public punishment punish purity questions quid pro quo racial racism rags ransom rapture receiving reconciliation record reformation refuge rejoice relationship relativism religion repent rescue response resurrection rich man richard rich righteousness riots risen rock romans 11 romans6 routine rubbish rubies ruth 1 sacrament sacrifice sadness saint salt salvation sanctification satanic saul school science scientist scripture seasons sea self-esteem senior seraphim sermon servant service sexual immorality sexual orientation sexual shaltanis shatlanis sheep shepherd shield shrewd sight singleness sing sinners sinner sins sin slave to sin slavery slaves small catechism snowflake social distancing social media sola sophia sorry soul speaker sphere spiritualists star steward strength stress strong student loan substance suffering suicide supernatural surreal task-oriented teach technology temple temptation tertullian tetelestai texts the Promise theology thomas time titus 3 titus3 toil tomb tongues tragedy trap trials trinity triune trust in God trustworthy trust truth tweets type A unbelief unbelievers unity university unjust steward unwoke vestments victory video vine virgin virology visitation vocation voice vote waiting watermarked water weakness weak wealth wedding wept why will wisdom wise witness woke womb working worldview worship yahweh youth ministry youth zealots zechariah